Check out our brand new Local Poker Communities! Get updates and interact with poker players in your area.
Visit the United States Poker Community | Visit the California Poker Community | Read more about the Launch of P5s Local

fantasy football trade question

Reply to Thread
  1. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:12pm)

    who wins A or B

    A gets tim hightower and jason witten

    B gets tony scheffler and johnathan stewart
  2. Fife19 Fife19 is offline

    Halifax
    Canada

    Posts: 10,711
    Joined: Jun 06

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:25pm) in reply to johnnykills

    Team B is the winner(its a bit closer if your league doesnt have any points per return yards) But team B still has the big edge on this trade.
  3. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:27pm) in reply to johnnykills

    yea we dont have points per return
    Thread Starter
  4. jetsfan jetsfan is offline

    Melville, NY
    United States

    Posts: 580
    Joined: Jul 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:40pm) in reply to johnnykills

    i think it is very close. witten is the #1 or 2 fantasy TE for sure. Stewrt still has to prove himself IMO. Team B has more upside, but it is a fair trade.
  5. TheAlbatross TheAlbatross is online now

    Los Angeles, CA
    United States

    Posts: 6,893
    Joined: Sep 05

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:51pm) in reply to jetsfan

    I like what team A is getting simply b/c of Witten. He's prolly the best TE And since I dont want to make a separate thread for what is likely a dumb question, its stupid to keep Stephen Gostkowski on my roster when he has a bye right? I picked up Kasey, I should drop SG right?
  6. TheFirm53 TheFirm53 is offline

    Chicago, IL
    United States

    Posts: 6,508
    Joined: Nov 07

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 3:55pm) in reply to TheAlbatross

    i am kinda leaning towards A. Witten is nasty and Hightower might become the starting RB in zona before years end.

    Drop your kicker
  7. Fife19 Fife19 is offline

    Halifax
    Canada

    Posts: 10,711
    Joined: Jun 06

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 4:01pm) in reply to TheAlbatross

    Yes, drop him... No one cares about kickers. Hes not even top 10 in points for kickers so its not like losing him(if anyone does pick him up) would hurt you.

    Also, I agree that Witten will probably end up being the #1 TE in the league this year. Scheffler isnt that far behind though... Hes got a great offense and has 11 catches so far this season and gets looks in the redzone, compared to Wittens 20(wow, didnt think Witten had that many catches)

    Stewart>Hitower by a bunch though.

    This could all hinge on how deep the player is giving away Stewart. Personally, I have Stewart on my team and hes been on the bench for every game so far this year.
  8. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 4:08pm) in reply to johnnykills

    by the way .im B..i'll be getting A if i accept. my rb's are portis jamal lewis ronnie brown and j stewart right now for those of you wondering what my other rb's are
    Thread Starter
  9. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 4:22pm) in reply to johnnykills

    just want a couple more opinions b4 i'll b ok with a decision
    Thread Starter
  10. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:15pm) in reply to johnnykills

    bump
    Thread Starter
  11. The Precedent The Precedent is offline

    Brattleboro, VT
    United States

    Posts: 5,699
    Joined: Dec 06

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:18pm) in reply to johnnykills

    B..
  12. Neeek Neeek is offline

    Kansas City, MO
    United States

    Posts: 8,349
    Joined: Sep 05

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:18pm) in reply to johnnykills

    hightower/witten is much better IMO. Scheffler is decent, but hard to get cathces with marshall and royal. there is no reason to believe stewart will overtake the starting job. he is good for a TD a week, but not much on yardage. Jason Witten owns.

    i consider hightower/stewart pretty even. so its witten for scheffler . . . .pretty obvious who is WAY better there.
  13. BigJohn804 BigJohn804 is offline

    Midlothian, VA
    United States

    Posts: 3,735
    Joined: Feb 06

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:19pm) in reply to johnnykills

    meh, hard to say without knowing his team too, but it would seem that you are upgrading him at RB while acheiving a minor upgrade at TE. And it's only an upgrade if its point for reception league.

    I don't see any reason to give up Stewart and Scheffler here unless you really rate Witten that much higher.
  14. johnnykills johnnykills is offline

    Posts: 67
    Joined: Sep 08

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:23pm) in reply to BigJohn804

    what about making it fasano and johnathan stewart for witten and hightower/
    Thread Starter
  15. R_U_Nuts R_U_Nuts is offline

    South Bend, IN
    United States

    Posts: 7,865
    Joined: Jan 07

    Sep 24th, 2008 (9/24/2008 5:27pm) in reply to Fife19

     
    Originally Posted by Fife19 View Post

    Team B is the winner(its a bit closer if your league doesnt have any points per return yards) But team B still has the big edge on this trade.

Reply to Thread

Similar Threads