-
well enforcing a no fly zone is very similar to a declaration of war. Libya/gaddafhi might not technically declare war on us if a no fly zone was instituted because he knows thats a war he can't win, but we would certainly become enemies.
Originally Posted by ginwilly
STD, I don't think Jeff or anyone is suggesting we go to war over this. The plan I keep hearing is enforce a no fly zone so the crazy fucker won't open fire over crowds. If our government ever reached the point where they opened fire on the daily wackos on Pennsylvania Ave I would hope another government would try to prevent it from happening again.
I think everyone is trying to figure out a way to threaten him into leaving, but it's not going to happen. We can't even think about more empty threats from the US, North Korea would go nuts. If we do make these threats we better be willing to shoot people out of the sky, because the crazy fucker is going to call any bluff.
A good reason for us to just stay the fuck out of this is it's just the beginning over there and no way can we get involved in all of them, especially when each new uprising may be worse than the last.
Waiting until the Saudi Sheiks start panicking so we can make them our bitches instead of the opposite is a viable option too.
Also this no fly zone might only serve to prolong the war. (it will neutralize gaddafhis air superiority, which would make it more difficult for him to end the uprising) GRANTEd it could also speed up the process if the rebels are the winning side. -
@emcee21
woah, woah, woah
it was a friendly poke in the ribs; just b/c i made a few posts that were not glib and snarky doesnt mean im not glib and snarky
@Willywoo
lol, save the cynicism for court, counsellor
@ginwilly
gtfo with the appeal to another govt intervening in our affairs, whatever the case
meaningless argumentative technique -
Arabs killing Arabs....Duh "Winning"
-
orrrrr....
Originally Posted by Z-Fresh
When a country's citizens rise up on their own to overthrow a dictator for democracy and ask the US for help is when we should take part IMO.
Perhaps you just dont hear the screams of the other people begging us for help through the media?
How many exactly does it take to become ok with msnbc?
Or does a democrat just have to be in office?
The hard hitting unpopular questions people should be just asking. -
Bout tree fiddy
-
Interesting thread
Stay away. If the world wants to get involved have the international community do it. We shouldn't be shooting down planes on our own--intl community maybe
The US should have people on the ground, CIA I'd imagine having influence in a new regime that will be friendly to our interest, style of government is overrated.
Think it was saxman who made good points about the Middle East/Arab world being very tribal. That is extremely important to understanding what styles of government will work. Plus doubt Lybia has a strong middle class and the other qualities that make for a strong democracy. Lots of good points in this thread from people I often disagree with (usually agree with sax). -
A no fly zone is needed. Its what a lot of Libyans seem to want. However they do not want a US or any other military invading their country. Implement a no fly zone and help out with humanitarian aid, thats what they need. Theres no doubt the US already has people on the ground like the UK had (that turned out loltastically).
Edited By: Clerk Mar 10th, 2011 at 01:31 PM
Edit: also some1 posted a pic claiming Hugo Chavez was responsible for genocide, links to evidence please? I don't think Chavez should still be in power but i've never heard about him committing genocide. -
The Colombian president accused Chavez of genocide because they claim they had evidence Venezuela gave money to a rebel group but that was a long time ago, couple years.
but really, socialism-genocide. Is there a difference? -
how many of their citizens? Do we need to go in and take a poll? Robert Heinlein once said a very smart thing, you can't be given freedom you must earn it or you will be unable to keep it. Look at all the "success" stories of us going in and "freeing" a people from a bad regime. Not one of those countries is what you would call stable, some decades later.
-
Libya may be Northern Africa but they are Arab. They are Sunni Muslim, speak Arabic, have some islamic law, "Arab nationalism", and uhh have Arab in the name of their country. It is an Arab state
Edited By: Zeppelin Mar 10th, 2011 at 02:43 PM
Edit: since some people don't know Iran & Turkey are not Arab states. Both have Arab minorities that are discriminated against. -
A no fly zone won't prevent the kidnaps, tourture and execution. We should not be invading a third country at this time. Why should American lives be lost and billions spent on this civil dispute? It's horrible but so is so much in this world. It's time to fix america. Entering another battle field will only perpetuate our fall and cause further instability to an unstable region.
Edited By: TheFirm53 Mar 10th, 2011 at 03:13 PM
War is never easy and rarely right. -
Relax guy. The david cameron is sending british jets in... oh wait, we don't have any jets anymore.
-
Ron Paul ftw -
Ron Paul nailed it
-
Always enjoy listening to Paul talk foreign policy
-
Edited By: norcaljeff Mar 11th, 2011 at 12:35 AMlol is this guy for real? no, imposing a no fly zone is not like a war. Oh but quadaffi might get upset and declare war on us? Oh Noes! wtf is he going to do? lol what a joke. Be careful, that dicator on the run in his own country is going to...uh...hmm.Originally Posted by penileinfection
well enforcing a no fly zone is very similar to a declaration of war. Libya/gaddafhi might not technically declare war on us if a no fly zone was instituted because he knows thats a war he can't win, but we would certainly become enemies.
Also this no fly zone might only serve to prolong the war. (it will neutralize gaddafhis air superiority, which would make it more difficult for him to end the uprising) GRANTEd it could also speed up the process if the rebels are the winning side.
and the no fly zone could prolong the war because he couldn't kill his people faster. good point? I agree! lol tf?
and holy shit ron paul is a fucking retard.
-
U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates was cautious on this option (no fly-zone), warning the U.S. Congress that a no-fly zone would have to begin with an attack on Libya’s air defenses and would require "a big operation in a big country."
Edited By: LuckyWilbury Mar 11th, 2011 at 12:45 AM
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/03/wo...tary.html?_r=1
Secretary of Defense opinion>ncj opinion imo -
we could do it with planes off the coast and ships.
wsj:
Unlike in the Balkans and Iraq, Libya's most populated cities and airbases are situated near its coastline, with most located less than 10 miles from the shore. In addition, due to the fracturing of the Libyan military, Gadhafi's forces have limited capability to retaliate. Thus it may be possible to enforce a no-fly zone without putting a single coalition plane directly over Libyan territory.
This approach would use precision-guided weapons to keep U.S. and allied planes out of range of Libya's air force and air defenses.
Rather than putting combat air patrols over Libya, it would employ ships and aircraft operating off the coast. Libyan aircraft violating the no-fly zone could be intercepted using ships armed with SM-2 surface-to-air missiles and fighter aircraft armed with AIM-120 air-to-air missiles, which can hit targets beyond visual range.
...
This approach would obviate the need to suppress Libyan air defenses before imposing a no-fly zone, since coalition aircraft would operate beyond their effective range. In addition, rather than employing aircraft from carriers, it would use a much smaller number of land-based combat aircraft that can be refueled in the air.
article by james thomas & zachary cooper 3/9/11 fyi fwiw -
Unfortunately, I think we will find out who is right.
-
What the fuck kind of thing is that to say?
-
Thats not what I was sarcastically hinting at. I was thinking more along the lines of the US funding Iraq and Israel. As well as all the other bullshit they get into like Nicaragua.













