1. Does that make her your uncle?

    Anyhow, something I've been thinking about for a while is same sex couples having children. I have some first hand experience with seeing same sex couples interacting with children, because my ex-wife's dad is gay and lives with his lover. Granted they both treat Eva very well and spoil her a ton, but while Gary is her grandpa...what should she call his lover, Mike? This isn't the same thing as a same sex couple adopting and being parents, and they obviously don't have the same influence over my daughter as a couple who adopted a child would have over said child. That said, it's still an awkward situation and if I'm being honest, I don't like it when she's by herself with those two especially if it's over night.

    What do you guys think?

    Oh, I'll add this bit as well: Both Gary and Mike have children from marriages they were involved in before they met each other. Mike was a counselor for Alcoholics Anonymous and Gary attended his sessions, that's how they met. Mike has 3 kids, and Gary has 2 of his own. This is yet another reason I am not convinced of the "you're born gay" theory. These two men led lives which involved women and children and marriage to the opposite sex, until they were both over the age of 40. Mike and I actually had a pretty heated discussion recently, and that is what brought me to think about this more as of late.
  2. y are you uncomfortable if she stays there over night? gay = pedo now? not like they are fucking in front of the kid. tell me you wouldnt be appalled if a straight couple did the same thing?

    and no shit your born gay, just how racism is taught.

    and finally if i had wheels, id be a bus.

    edit: to answer your question theyre both grandpa. anything else will just confuse her.
  3. Gary = Grandpa
    Mike = Grandma
  4. I believe the more time she spends in an environment with two gay adults, the more she will be influenced to think that behavior/sexual orientation is OK...and that's not something she should be influenced with one way or the other IMO. I would not/do not want morality being taught to my daughter by them. (A lot of that has to do with what I've seen in my ex-wife, and I shudder to think my daughter would hold some of the same beliefs and carry the same attitude as she does )
    Thread Starter
  5.  
    Originally Posted by WeyNot View Post


    Gary = Grand<strike>pa</strike>ma
    Mike = Grand<strike>ma</strike>pa

    FYP
  6. Grandpa Mike and Grandpa Gary? Call one Grandpa, and one Grandad? How do kids normally differentiate between their two grandparents of the same sex anyway?

    Why are you unconfortable with her staying by herself with them, especially overnight?

    Do you think they were born straight, but decided to turn gay when they became middle aged? Some strong external influences there it seems. Or, perhaps they were born gay, but because of societal pressure (especially back in those days) they led 'normal' straight lives because they felt pressured into doing so. Or even maybe they were born bisexual (with a stronger tendancy towards homosexual), meaning it felt easyish to lead a straight life, which, let's face it, would have led to far less persecution as compared to their actual preference.
  7.  
    Originally Posted by DJam21 View Post

    Or, perhaps they were born gay, but because of societal pressure (especially back in those days) they led 'normal' straight lives because they felt pressured into doing so. Or even maybe they were born bisexual (with a stronger tendancy towards homosexual), meaning it felt easyish to lead a straight life, which, let's face it, would have led to far less persecution as compared to their actual preference.

    This is one of those things I will admit to being close minded about. I will never believe being gay is NOT a choice. I'm sure I'll get blasted for that statement, but I really DGAF.
    Thread Starter
  8.  
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post

    I believe the more time she spends in an environment with two gay adults, the more she will be influenced to think that behavior/sexual orientation is OK

    What behaviours precisely - dirty, immoral man-sex, right? And yes, ftr homosexual orientation/behaviour IS ok.

     
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post

    and that's not something she should be influenced with one way or the other IMO.

    So by the same token, you wouldn't want a straight couple looking after her overnight?

     
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post

    I would not/do not want morality being taught to my daughter by them. (A lot of that has to do with what I've seen in my ex-wife, and I shudder to think my daughter would hold some of the same beliefs and carry the same attitude as she does )

    I'm guessing your ex-wife has some dubious morals; fair enough. Do you think then that Gary and Mike share the same negative morals?
  9. Wow, it took 1 response to equate you not wanting your daughter spending the night in a home of two gay men to = pedo concerns? This is obviously not the case at all here for OneM.

    Everyone has different core values, aspects of life that are considered of vital importance and in many cases a set of beliefs that a person molds a life around. Everyone has different values in their lives and we are all free to live by what we see fit. I see the same thing in how we raise our kids and what you want them to have as their own core values.

    There is nothing wrong with OneM not wanting his daughter around any type of situation or environment that revovles around things he would not care for her to witness. There are FAR more situations these same arguments can be applied to, especially if you get into religion and schooling/education.

    I also agree with OneM on "not being born gay", but I am sure this thread will turn into a shitshow so whatever on that one.
  10.  
    Originally Posted by HK_MP5N View Post

    There is nothing wrong with OneM not wanting his daughter around any type of situation or environment that revovles around things he would not care for her to witness.

    This.

    As a parent, I have a right to decide what I do and do not want my daughter to be around. I have an obligation to ensure she is being raised properly, and in an environment which will help define what she believes to be acceptable behavior.

    To answer a question posed, yes I do feel as if Gary and Mike influenced Hayley's decisions before, during, and after we were married. I'm not going to get into specifics, but I will say the things believed to be perfectly ok behavior for and by them, are NOT ok for me and I do not want my daughter acting that way. Some of those things include being selfish, immoral, and unethical.
    Thread Starter
  11. I don't think many people are going to argue that you have the right to decide how your daughter is raised. What is being questioned are the reasonings behind it.

     
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post

    Some of those things include being selfish, immoral, and unethical.

    Yes, these are bad traits. Are you suggesting they're linked to homosexuality?
  12.  
    Originally Posted by DJam21 View Post

    I don't think many people are going to argue that you have the right to decide how your daughter is raised. What is being questioned are the reasonings behind it.

    Yes, these are bad traits. Are you suggesting they're linked to homosexuality?

    Not necessarily so, but they could be additional traits he has witnessed in them besides the homosexual behaviors.
  13. Some scientists will tell you that gender is not an either/or situation, but more of a spectrum.

    Just for illustration purposes, a lot of men are fully XY and brutally masculine (like myself). Other men may be more XY with the Y being a little split at the bottom, making him a little fem (closer to XX), but not necessarily gay.

    Its the same with women ie XX with the Legs on one X closing up a little (closer to XY) making them more manly... etc.

    With all that said, most people are born fully XY or XX and wouldn't ever be gay.
    Some people are born completely gay. And the final group, depending on their place on the gender spectrum, could be convinced or decide to become gay if conditions are appropriate.
  14.  
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post

    I believe the more time she spends in an environment with two gay adults, the more she will be influenced to think that behavior/sexual orientation is OK...and that's not something she should be influenced with one way or the other IMO.

    I'm not a fan of that statement because I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with people being homosexual. I understand you would prefer to educate your child about sex on your own terms but that's really unrealistic. Maybe you don't want your daughter to grow up with an open mind and would prefer her to think homosexuality is a sin. As a father you have those rights but the mother has rights as well and as long as she isn't putting your daughter at actual harm than you are going to have to come to compromise.
  15.  
    Originally Posted by HK_MP5N View Post

    Not necessarily so, but they could be additional traits he has witnessed in them besides the homosexual behaviors.

    So long as we're clear that homosexuality has nothing to do with the bad traits mentioned.
  16. This thread is heading straight towards shitland.

    OneM, if science proved that being gay wasn't a choice, what would you say? Claim ignorance?
     
  17.  
    Originally Posted by TheFirm53 View Post

    Maybe you don't want your daughter to grow up with an open mind

    My daughter can, should, will, and does have an open mind about many things. Human sexuality is not one of them.
    Thread Starter
  18. So what happens if your daughter grows up and realizes she prefers women? Was it the gay grandparents fault? Your fault? and Will you disown her?
  19.  
    Originally Posted by Leet8s View Post

    OneM, if science proved that being gay wasn't a choice, what would you say? Claim ignorance?

    I would say those people looking for a reason for science to prove being gay isn't a choice, are tailoring results from their "scientific research" to fit what they want to find, and not what is necessarily true. How many times has something been deemed as fact in the name of "science", and has later been disproven? No, this is one of those things where you can submit so called evidence for both arguments and each may have valid points. That said, any argument claiming genetic link to being homosexual is not logical and I will not entertain it...regardless of whatever "evidence" is submitted.
    Thread Starter
  20. Your daughter can't have an open mind about human sexuality?

    Wow. That's very sad.
  21. cb04 and I would golf with my father inlaw and his friend every Sunday over summer and he would always say that:
    If your aunt had balls, then she'd be your uncle.

    i didn't read the rest of the OP, so i have no other contribution to make
  22.  
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post


    My daughter can, should, will, and does have an open mind about many things. Human sexuality is not one of them.

    Expand
  23.  
    Originally Posted by TheFirm53 View Post

    So what happens if your daughter grows up and realizes she prefers women? Was it the gay grandparents fault? Your fault? and Will you disown her?

    I was waiting on this question, it ALWAYS comes up in this type of discussion. I would say there are many things in today's society that could lead to somebody making the decision to be homosexual. Perhaps it would be a mixture of the influence of grandparent and his partner, the glorified gay pride parades, television exposure that is distasteful but casts that behavior in a positive light (which I dislike extremely), and a myriad of other things.

    And with all due respect, GTFO with the disown question. It doesn't even deserve a response.
    Thread Starter
  24. many children have two grandfathers in their lives - i would assume she would differentiate between them the same way most families deal with this - by calling them two different things - in our household, for instance, my dad is "Grandpa" and the hubby's dad is "Pops"

    i understand that you have reservations about having your daughter spend time with her homosexual grandparents, but you do need to realize that the child's mother also has some say in how her daughter is raised - if you don't like that she is exposed to lifestyles that you don't approve of, you're free to teach her your views on morality, but to deny her the relationship or contact with her mother's parents is wrong

    you know i <3 you, onem, but i will never understand ppl who truly believe that homosexuality is a choice - for some, maybe it is these days - but who would choose to be ostracized and discriminated against the way gays have been and continue to be? who would choose to be treated as a second-class citizen?*

    to state that homosexuality is unnatural seems absurd when you take a look at nature - it's really not all that uncommon - we are animals, after all
  25.  
    Originally Posted by Brooklyn999 View Post

    Your daughter can't have an open mind about human sexuality?

    Wow. That's very sad.

    Why is it sad? The purpose of human sexuality is for reproduction. Two males cannot reproduce, and neither can two females. What is there to debate?
    Thread Starter
  26.  
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post


    I would say those people looking for a reason for science to prove being gay isn't a choice, are tailoring results from their "scientific research" to fit what they want to find, and not what is necessarily true. How many times has something been deemed as fact in the name of "science", and has later been disproven? No, this is one of those things where you can submit so called evidence for both arguments and each may have valid points. That said, any argument claiming genetic link to being homosexual is not logical and I will not entertain it...regardless of whatever "evidence" is submitted.

    what? so you'll just cover your ears and start singing something very loud? btw, do you also still think that the earth is flat?
  27. Well you stated your child can't have an open mind about human sexuality so it wouldn't seem far fetched to assume that you would have strong negative feelings towards her had she disobeyed your teachings.

    I have a gay sister so I have some first hand knowledge on the subject.
  28. I think you guys should call them Tranma and Tranpa
     
  29.  
    Originally Posted by OneM24 View Post


    That said, any argument claiming genetic link to being homosexual is not logical and I will not entertain it...regardless of whatever "evidence" is submitted.*

    how is it not logical? people are born with all sorts of abnormalities of one form or another, why would you exclude sexuality as a possibility?
  30. I realize her mother has some say, but just because she has some say does not mean I have to agree with what she is saying. I really have no desire for her to not have a relationship with her grandpa, but it's a catch 22 for me. My views on morality will be very well known to her as she grows older.

     
    Originally Posted by pigalet42 View Post

    but who would choose to be ostracized and discriminated against the way gays have been and continue to be? who would choose to be treated as a second-class citizen?

    The craving of attention is a powerful thing. Also, men and women who are abused as children often shy away from the sex that abused them as they get older. This could also be a contributing circumstance. It's only one argument, but you get my point. I know many kids that "acted" gay (especially females) while in high school, just to get the attention. Sometimes people don't care that it's negative attention, it's the fact that they are getting it at all that matters to them.
    Thread Starter

Similar Threads