Visit the United States Poker Community | Visit the California Poker Community | Read more about the Launch of P5s Local
-
For the life of me I don't understand how you can be a replay official and still get shit wrong. It happens every effin week and they just blew a huge call in the Bama/LSUgame( for the record I don't care who wins so this has nothing to do with anything) ... Why is this so hard
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:02pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.
-
Posts: 6,302
Joined: Nov 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:05pm) in reply to LDM
Instant replay was put into use to GET THE CALL RIGHTOriginally Posted by LDM
the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.
They did not and it wasn't that hard a decision since he got 2 feet in and only needed one
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Posts: 15,092
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:05pm) in reply to LDM
The worst part was that the first replay CBS showed, from behind the play (defense's perspective) CLEARLY showed BOTH feet come down in bounds. Instead they show the same two replays that give you no idea whether the right foot came down in bounds. Fact is he got BOTH feet down, and there was CLEAR evidence to overturn it. DVR the thing. Go back and look at the very first replay CBS showed. It's clear as day that he gets his right foot down in bounds, too.Originally Posted by LDM
the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.
-
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:12pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
you all do realize that you have to get a foot down AFTER possession right? and because he was in the act of tucking the ball possession didn't start until it was tucked.
i still think it was a pick, but a hell of a lot closer than what you guys thought. and that's why replay didn't overturn. the call on the field decided the play. -
Posts: 15,092
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:21pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
Nope, didn't even come close to doing well. It's Stud8. You know how it goes.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
6:10 P.M. CST marinersheep and orgnalsooners totally agree !!!!! hope u did well with all stud 8 chips I gave u the other day...
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Posts: 4,593
Joined: May 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:22pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
when i read "instant replay is a joke" i couldn't help but be disappointed when i opened the thread and didn't see:
instant replay walked into a bar, then it walked into a bar again, slower. -
Posts: 6,302
Joined: Nov 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:30pm) in reply to LDM
Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer? The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND 2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here. I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFOOriginally Posted by LDM
you all do realize that you have to get a foot down AFTER possession right? and because he was in the act of tucking the ball possession didn't start until it was tucked.
i still think it was a pick, but a hell of a lot closer than what you guys thought. and that's why replay didn't overturn. the call on the field decided the play.
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:46pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
I didn't write the rules. NCAA catch/possession rule about tucking a catch says it's possessed once tucked, not before.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer? The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND 2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here. I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFO
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
There was only one foot in question after the tuck, and it was close. I say it was in, Replay official said it wasn't enough to overturn.
The call on the field still decided. -
Posts: 2,711
Joined: Jan 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:48pm) in reply to LDM
I didnt think it was a pick....
-
Trent55
can i have a title now
Posts: 8,510
Joined: Oct 05Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:51pm) in reply to LDM
college football reviews are god awful theres been plenty of calls that should have been overturned. i never thought id say this but i can hardly stand watching football anymore bc of the refs having so much influence these days!. mostly the gay ass touching the qb with your pinky and its an auto 15 yds. or the ball carrier lowers his shoulder and helmets make contact and you get 15 yds. its fucking embarassing
-
Trent55
can i have a title now
Posts: 8,510
Joined: Oct 05Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 6:52pm) in reply to swizbeatz
lol nice levelOriginally Posted by swizbeatz
I didnt think it was a pick....
-
Posts: 2,313
Joined: Aug 08Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 7:14pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
being a douche bag doesn't make your argument better.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer? The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND 2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here. I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFO
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
Bama homer here. -
Posts: 6,302
Joined: Nov 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 8:43pm) in reply to BadAllergies
Not being a douche at all and in fact hope he is just a homer b/c it is OBVIOUS to anyone with a brain that he was in, that's it, no discussion, it's a factttttt. And u do not have to tuck the ball for it to be a catch whatsoever.... You have to have clear possession with 1 foot in.... Period
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Trent55
can i have a title now
Posts: 8,510
Joined: Oct 05Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 8:45pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
Houston Tulsa Game, that ball did not fucking touch that guy and the call stands? seriously this is a fuckin joke
-
Posts: 2,313
Joined: Aug 08Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:09pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
well. Clearly, it's not a fact.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
Not being a douche at all and in fact hope he is just a homer b/c it is OBVIOUS to anyone with a brain that he was in, that's it, no discussion, it's a factttttt. And u do not have to tuck the ball for it to be a catch whatsoever.... You have to have clear possession with 1 foot in.... Period
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
If the ruling on the field was an interception, they would have not overturned it either.
The ruling on the field in this case made all the difference. -
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:21pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
it's got to take a lot of practice to be as ignorant as you.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
Not being a douche at all and in fact hope he is just a homer b/c it is OBVIOUS to anyone with a brain that he was in, that's it, no discussion, it's a factttttt. And u do not have to tuck the ball for it to be a catch whatsoever.... You have to have clear possession with 1 foot in.... Period
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
at no point did i say it wasn't an interception, IN MY OPINION. but since it was called incomplete, ref needed undisputed proof to overturn. OBV if they thought he had possession as soon as the ball hit his hands, then he got two feet in. Unfortunately, you're dumbass doesn't know NCAA rulings. You can here Verne commenting on the fact since the player was in the act of tucking it's not secured til it's tucked.
Since the player OFFICIALLY had possession after it was tucked there was only one foot in question. and it was close to the sideline and not conclusive in any way, shape, or form.
Officially the play couldn't be overturned.
Officially you are a douche and a dumbass to boot. -
Posts: 2,313
Joined: Aug 08Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:26pm) in reply to LDM
AgreeOriginally Posted by LDM
Officially the play couldn't be overturned.
Officially you are a douche and a dumbass to boot.
OP is just a bitter Big 12 fan wishing he could root for a SEC team -
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:35pm) in reply to BadAllergies
FTR my team got doubled up by UT to the tune of 56-28. I hate the SEC, but live in the middle of the conference.
-
Posts: 18,276
Joined: Jul 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:36pm) in reply to LDM
What if a DB/WR never tucks the ball?Originally Posted by LDM
I didn't write the rules. NCAA catch/possession rule about tucking a catch says it's possessed once tucked, not before.
There was only one foot in question after the tuck, and it was close. I say it was in, Replay official said it wasn't enough to overturn.
The call on the field still decided.
There are plenty of times when a WR will make a catch and never tuck it...they'll reach for the goalline instead. AFAIK, reaching for the goalline would constitute possession of the ball, right?
I don't see why this would be any different. -
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:41pm) in reply to JRoth15
listen to verne and danielaksdnflks whatever the other guy's name is. if you listen to the commentators they allude to the Tuck Rule<sub>A</sub> (we all know Brady owns the true Tuck Rule). I can't remember what game i was watching, but the ruled a pass incomplete because dude was still in one motion.
-
Posts: 7,818
Joined: Feb 06Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:42pm) in reply to BadAllergies
This is all i was trying to say. Guess i'm not as good a woodsmith as you. Hope these guys don't jump your shit too. LOLOriginally Posted by BadAllergies
well. Clearly, it's not a fact.
If the ruling on the field was an interception, they would have not overturned it either.
The ruling on the field in this case made all the difference. -
Posts: 6,302
Joined: Nov 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:45pm) in reply to LDM
Yeah, I am the dumbass here who can hear, lol. Well if Verne Lundquist says it, it must be true. I can't believe you are continuing with this tuck shit... How many times do players catch the ball and never tuck it? The NCAA rules website is down so I can't post it but if you watch any amount of football whatsoever you should know that you do not have to tuck the ball.Originally Posted by LDM
it's got to take a lot of practice to be as ignorant as you.
at no point did i say it wasn't an interception, IN MY OPINION. but since it was called incomplete, ref needed undisputed proof to overturn. OBV if they thought he had possession as soon as the ball hit his hands, then he got two feet in. Unfortunately, you're dumbass doesn't know NCAA rulings. You can here Verne commenting on the fact since the player was in the act of tucking it's not secured til it's tucked.
Since the player OFFICIALLY had possession after it was tucked there was only one foot in question. and it was close to the sideline and not conclusive in any way, shape, or form.
Officially the play couldn't be overturned.
Officially you are a douche and a dumbass to boot.
U and another Bama homer are the only 2 disputing that it was not conclusive whereas everyone else is being objective... Like I said, I have nothing vested in either team whatsoever so I am completely unbiased but I can call it as I clearly see it, not as I want it to be. Kinda funny that you're trying to call me out on something that you are 100% wrong about... Watch the rest of football for the evening and see if every ball is tucked or called incomplete, seriously.
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden"> -
Posts: 2,008
Joined: Mar 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:49pm) in reply to LDM
I dont understand why replay doesn't use the 360 cams like ESPN has at games. I mean in this day and age we cant tell exactly if a player has a foot in bounds or crosses the goal line?
I get the feeling that the replay officials don't want to overturn many of the officials calls because of the impression it may give about officiating. I hate seeing the stats like only 6 of 39 reviewed plays in the Big 12 this year have been overturned, thats bullshit. -
Posts: 2,313
Joined: Aug 08Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:51pm) in reply to orgnalsooners
you're missing the point.Originally Posted by orgnalsooners
Yeah, I am the dumbass here who can hear, lol. Well if Verne Lundquist says it, it must be true. I can't believe you are continuing with this tuck shit... How many times do players catch the ball and never tuck it? The NCAA rules website is down so I can't post it but if you watch any amount of football whatsoever you should know that you do not have to tuck the ball.
U and another Bama homer are the only 2 disputing that it was not conclusive whereas everyone else is being objective... Like I said, I have nothing vested in either team whatsoever so I am completely unbiased but I can call it as I clearly see it, not as I want it to be. Kinda funny that you're trying to call me out on something that you are 100% wrong about... Watch the rest of football for the evening and see if every ball is tucked or called incomplete, seriously.
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
The ruling on the field is what is important here.
Video wasn't clear enough for the replay ref to overturn(in his opinion), thus the ruling on the field stands.
IMO if it had been called an interception on the field, it would have stood as an interception -
Posts: 6,302
Joined: Nov 07Nov 7th, 2009 (11/7/2009 9:54pm) in reply to BlindBuddah
marinersheep made a gr8 point in that the officials see the replays that we see and even though it was conclusive from the replay it was sooooooooooooo much more from the back angle that they first showed but never showed again.... Officials HATEOriginally Posted by BlindBuddah
I dont understand why replay doesn't use the 360 cams like ESPN has at games. I mean in this day and age we cant tell exactly if a player has a foot in bounds or crosses the goal line?
I get the feeling that the replay officials don't want to overturn many of the officials calls because of the impression it may give about officiating. I hate seeing the stats like only 6 of 39 reviewed plays in the Big 12 this year have been overturned, thats bullshit.
being wrong and maybe they hate it more than getting it right but this thread has run it's course. It was a bad call and I wish I had video of that DB pullin a Deion Sanders running down the field with with the ball over his heads never tucked from earlier this year so I could make my point via video but w/e.
<input id="gwProxy" type="hidden"><input onclick="jsCall();" id="jsProxy" type="hidden">
Similar Threads
-
Top Recommended Site
DraftDay
New DraftDay users get a free $5 heads-up draft just for trying out the site Click Here -
Profanity Sports
50% Deposit Bonus with Promo Code FIVES Click Here -
Buzzdraft
30% deposit bonus up to $150 with Promo Code FIVES Click Here -
FanDuel
Qualify for the $250,000 Daily Fantasy Baseball Championship Click Here -
PocketFives Monthly PLB
Player Score 1 Grip 3,559.38 2 Flush_Entity 3,248.29 3 Gettin Daize 3,231.71 4 matfrankland 3,081.68 5 ahustla16 2,993.75 6 LeChiffre19 2,779.79 7 moorman1 2,751.80 8 Naza114 2,591.01 9 RenRad 01 2,581.95 10 Mutha Flushaa 2,568.30 -
Recent PocketFives Awards
-
Its nap time
$1 million
May 25th, 2012
-
aces_up4108
Triple Crown
May 25th, 2012
-
ruxandescu
$500k
May 24th, 2012
-
-
Grip
$3 million
May 22nd, 2012
-
Best places to play daily fantasy sports
Tweets from P5ers
Wheresmykiss
2012-05-26 01:17:09
Andys hot frys #andyshotrfries @SlimSchade. @BrockusKhan @sfmandish
JasonKoon
2012-05-26 01:16:51
Grats to my boy @BigCheese_poker for winning the Bellagio 100k for 1.3 Milly! Have a feeling we are doing it up tomorrow!
JasonKoon
2012-05-26 01:15:48
RT @WorldPokerTour: Congrats @BigCheese_poker on winning the @BellagioPoker Super HR! http://t.co/bVb44P7l
ChrisBrauch
2012-05-26 01:07:21
Laying on my bed torn between drunken sleep and drunken texting #fwproblems
Psutennis
2012-05-26 01:06:13
Got pulled over in Kansas doing 88.. Fortunately the speed limit was 75 and we got a warning.. #definitelystillinkansasdorothy
CollinCapone
2012-05-26 01:00:26
So glad the Devils won, gonna be a way more exciting final now. The Rangers are the Devils of old. #nhl
Sambrosie
2012-05-26 00:58:09
At Marquee with @RachHuseby for Benny Benassi #ballin
RichMuny
2012-05-26 00:57:40
Saturday #Poker Daily Action Plan: Let's tell GOP House leadership to support poker! http://t.co/0sj83IU2
Stee1rz_Fanz
2012-05-26 00:56:05
RT @TeamMizrachi: If @TheGrinder44 wins the WPT event tom he will pass @phil_hellmuth in career earnings & would be in 4th behind @P ...
toill3
2012-05-26 00:54:00
watching the @worldpokertour live stream sick 47>10s hand.
AShoeToe
2012-05-26 00:53:39
@Andrew_Robl had him dead to three outs for the ship. It's cool tho, keep mashing this fool. #WPThighroller
Andressoprano
2012-05-26 00:51:57
I can't say in public that I'm afraid of you RT @DuckUPoker1: @Andressoprano right, right... I'm sure you are...
TimDaChimp
2012-05-26 00:42:36
Maridu
2012-05-26 00:42:09
e boa noite que essa semana foi UM SONHO no cash e amanhã promete. Temos % comprado de finalista do WPT e peixinhos nadando no mar <3
Maridu
2012-05-26 00:40:14
se vc está vendendo % pro main event do WSOP (sem ser a palhaçada dos preços das cavaladas no BR) me manda DM. Soh main event interessa. ty
Aaronsaulgood
2012-05-26 00:35:51
Mariners, you're killin me. Let's let poker allow me to forget about you one time
chicagocards1
2012-05-26 00:32:43
Wonder if I'm ever on time I bet people hate me #stillshowupearlyrelativetolivetournies
Samtrickett1
2012-05-26 00:16:38
http://t.co/tBYLEQ55
AnnieDuke
2012-05-26 00:15:32
Yay! My new book is a "Hot New Release" on Amazon. So exciting! http://t.co/QEvITMBH
TimDaChimp
2012-05-26 00:14:33
TimDaChimp
2012-05-26 00:13:42
The_DFish
2012-05-26 00:10:57
Scarlett's nights > http://t.co/HlX9sycI
Justin_Zaki
2012-05-26 00:06:51
Tampa Bay with another beat down of Boston. Red Sox and their fans once again showing no class. Took the dude 4 attempts to hit our guy
TheReaLMander
2012-05-26 00:04:26
Busted with QQ vs ak and kk aip with like an hour n a half left in the day. Gg. Gl to pals remaining
bazeman11
2012-05-26 00:03:49
"@KeithFerrera: Several story high wine cellar at aureole for mine and Katie's 5 year anniversary http://t.co/jOza4fTC" #tnj
killahmcgillah
2012-05-26 00:02:18
the official rungood #WSOP cake: http://t.co/qAK3KEkP
TheTmay
2012-05-25 23:57:47
Rly haven't liked the rangers since messier..and I still don't. #gg
Maridu
2012-05-25 23:52:24
@elkypoker wanna come over this weekend, work out, go to pool, play Diablo, eat healthy, talk about living forever, etc etc? MISS YOU!
nanonoko
2012-05-25 23:42:30
Sometimes I feel lazy...
Moorman1
2012-05-25 23:39:01
Made it to VEGAS finally! plane delayed 4 hours but got all the run bad out the way Series starts on Monday, UFC + drinking tomoz night tho!
Andrew_Robl
2012-05-25 23:37:14
Heads up for the big money. Check out the live stream at http://t.co/xphp3Y4T.
CornellContra
2012-05-25 23:33:47
Officer-"How much have you had to drink?" Anonymous-"To be honest, not enough." lol..
P_RoZayy
2012-05-25 23:32:33
RT @TheComedySaying: Hide and seek champions = 1) Waldo. 2) Osama Bin Laden. 3) My phone when It's on silent.
aces_up4108
2012-05-25 23:32:16
Went to change gear but the gear stick broke... MotherF#$*%@!
Andressoprano
2012-05-25 23:30:29
Black Sabbath's "The mob rules" RT @NikkiSixx: What was the first album you ever bought?
PocketFives Rankings
| Player | PLB | PRO | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 |
Flush_Entity | 1st 7,569 |
2nd 15 |
|
2 |
Gettin Daize | 3rd 7,210 |
3rd 16 |
|
3 |
Big Huni | 9th 6,652 |
1st 14 |
|
4 |
weavel | 2nd 7,408 |
13th 28 |
|
5 |
mtstackin88 | 4th 7,034 |
10th 23 |
| Country | Top 20 PLB |
P5s Members |
Prev Rank |
||
| 1 |  Canada |
103770 | 1924 | 1st | |
| 2 |  United Kingdom |
102421 | 1855 | 2nd | |
| 3 |  Costa Rica |
89458 | 123 | 4th | |
| 4 |  Australia |
88336 | 994 | 3rd | |
| 5 |  Mexico |
87509 | 184 | 5th |
Denmark
Russian Federation
Sweden
Brazil
Germany
© 2012 PocketFives.com