Check out our brand new Local Poker Communities! Get updates and interact with poker players in your area.
Visit the United States Poker Community | Visit the California Poker Community | Read more about the Launch of P5s Local

Question about Keeper Leagues

Reply to Thread
  1. K2L55 K2L55 is offline

    Coral Gables, FL
    United States

    Posts: 208
    Joined: Apr 05

    Aug 30th, 2009 (8/30/2009 11:46pm)

    A group of 12 of us guys do a fantasy football league every year. Nothing big, just $60 or so, for bragging rights and what not. So, last year, we decided to make it a 2 keeper league. This year, there's a guy whose keepers are T.O. and ___ (choices are ray rice, braylon edwards, or laron mcclain) He's asking if he can only keep T.O. then pick up an extra draft pick at the end of the 2nd round. Am I being a dick by voting against this? We're all friends and hang out, but its not like having to keep 1 extra player is going to kill his team. Besides, Ray Rice could have a big year.

    Side note, my keepers are P. Manning and Steve Slaton right? Go Texans!

    <TABLE class=teamtable id=statTable0 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 border=0><THEAD> <TR class=headerRow0 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first"></TH><TH class=group title=Passing colSpan=3>Passing
    </TH><TH class=group title=Rushing colSpan=2>Rushing
    </TH><TH class=group title=Receiving colSpan=2>Receiving
    </TH><TH class=group title=Return>Ret
    </TH><TH class=group title=Miscellaneous>Misc
    </TH><TH class=group title=Fumbles>Fum
    </TH><TH class="pts last"></TH></TR><TR class=headerRow1 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first">Player
    </TH><TH class=stat>Yds
    </TH><TH class=stat>TD
    </TH><TH class=stat>Int
    </TH><TH class=stat>Yds
    </TH><TH class=stat>TD
    </TH><TH class=stat>Yds
    </TH><TH class=stat>TD
    </TH><TH class=stat>TD
    </TH><TH class=stat>2PT
    </TH><TH class=stat>Lost
    </TH><TH class="pts last">Fan Pts
    </TH></TR></THEAD> <TBODY><TR><TD class="playersimple first">Kevin Boss <SPAN>(NYG - TE)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>384</TD><TD class=stat>6</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">74.40</TD></TR><TR class=even><TD class="playersimple first">Daunte Culpepper <SPAN>(Det - QB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>786</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>6</TD><TD class=stat>25</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class="pts last">47.94</TD></TR><TR class=odd><TD class="playersimple first">David Garrard <SPAN>(Jac - QB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>3620</TD><TD class=stat>15</TD><TD class=stat>13</TD><TD class=stat>322</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>-6</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>3</TD><TD class="pts last">229.40</TD></TR><TR class=even><TD class="playersimple first">Anthony Gonzalez <SPAN>(Ind - WR)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>664</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">90.40</TD></TR><TR class=odd><TD class="playersimple first">Ryan Grant <SPAN>(GB - RB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1203</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>116</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>3</TD><TD class="pts last">155.90</TD></TR><TR class=even><TD class="playersimple first">Bryant Johnson <SPAN>(Det - WR)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>546</TD><TD class=stat>3</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">72.60</TD></TR><TR class=odd><TD class="playersimple first">Marshawn Lynch <SPAN>(Buf - RB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1036</TD><TD class=stat>8</TD><TD class=stat>300</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class="pts last">185.60</TD></TR><TR class=even><TD class="playersimple first">Peyton Manning <SPAN>(Ind - QB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>4002</TD><TD class=stat>27</TD><TD class=stat>12</TD><TD class=stat>21</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">266.18</TD></TR><TR class=odd><TD class="playersimple first">Santana Moss <SPAN>(Was - WR)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>27</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1044</TD><TD class=stat>6</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class="pts last">147.10</TD></TR><TR class=even><TD class="playersimple first">Chad Ochocinco <SPAN>(Cin - WR)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>540</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">78.00</TD></TR><TR class=odd><TD class="playersimple first">Steve Slaton <SPAN>(Hou - RB)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1282</TD><TD class=stat>9</TD><TD class=stat>377</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class="pts last">221.90</TD></TR><TR><TD class="playersimple first">Jason Witten <SPAN>(Dal - TE)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>42</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>952</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">120.88</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE> <TABLE class=teamtable id=statTable1 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 border=0><THEAD> <TR class=headerRow0 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first"></TH><TH class=group title="Field Goals Made" colSpan=5>Field Goals Made
    </TH><TH class=group title="Point After TD">PAT
    </TH><TH class="pts last"></TH></TR><TR class=headerRow1 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first">Player
    </TH><TH class=stat>0-19
    </TH><TH class=stat>20-29
    </TH><TH class=stat>30-39
    </TH><TH class=stat>40-49
    </TH><TH class=stat>50+
    </TH><TH class=stat>Made
    </TH><TH class="pts last">Fan Pts
    </TH></TR></THEAD> <TBODY><TR><TD class="playersimple first">David Akers <SPAN>(Phi - K)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>11</TD><TD class=stat>10</TD><TD class=stat>8</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>45</TD><TD class="pts last">156.00</TD></TR><TR><TD class="playersimple first">Stephen Gostkowski <SPAN>(NE - K)</SPAN></TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>10</TD><TD class=stat>16</TD><TD class=stat>9</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>40</TD><TD class="pts last">159.00</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE> <TABLE class=teamtable id=statTable2 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 border=0><THEAD> <TR class=headerRow0 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first"></TH><TH class=group title= ></TH><TH class=group title=Tackles colSpan=2>Tackles
    </TH><TH class=group title=Turnovers colSpan=2>Turnovers
    </TH><TH class=group title=Touchdowns>TD
    </TH><TH class=group title=Miscellaneous>Misc
    </TH><TH class="pts last"></TH></TR><TR class=headerRow1 vAlign=bottom><TH class="playersimple first">Player
    </TH><TH class=stat><SPAN class=pts-allowed>Pts Allow</SPAN>
    </TH><TH class=stat>Sack
    </TH><TH class=stat>Safe
    </TH><TH class=stat>Int
    </TH><TH class=stat><A target="_blank" rel="nofollow" href="http://archive.fantasysports.yahoo.com/archive/pnfl/2008/21240/rosters?mid=4&stat1=S&stat2=S_2008&sor t=34" >Fum
    Rec</A>
    </TH><TH class=stat>TD
    </TH><TH class=stat><A target="_blank" rel="nofollow" href="http://archive.fantasysports.yahoo.com/archive/pnfl/2008/21240/rosters?mid=4&stat1=S&stat2=S_2008&sor t=37" >Blk
    Kick</A>
    </TH><TH class="pts last">Fan Pts
    </TH></TR></THEAD> <TBODY><TR><TD class="playersimple first">Arizona <SPAN>(Ari - DEF)</SPAN></TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
  2. warden warden is offline

    Tucson, AZ
    United States

    Posts: 15,530
    Joined: Apr 06

    Aug 31st, 2009 (8/31/2009 12:15am) in reply to K2L55

    another pick at the end of the 2nd round is way better than all those choices so i'd definitely vote no
     2
  3. K2L55 K2L55 is offline

    Coral Gables, FL
    United States

    Posts: 208
    Joined: Apr 05

    Aug 31st, 2009 (8/31/2009 12:39am) in reply to warden

    By end of the 2nd round, I meant the 2nd round of "new" picks after the 2 rounds of keepers are inputted... still feel the same way dpottz?

    1stRound: 1st Keeper
    2ndRound: 2nd Keeper
    3rd Round: new pick
    4th: new pick
    ---where he would pick----
    Thread Starter
  4. jtown1010 jtown1010 is offline

    United States

    Posts: 23,112
    Joined: Jan 06

    Aug 31st, 2009 (8/31/2009 12:45am) in reply to K2L55

    Seems marginal, if everyone wants to do it I'd go for it, probably not if it's 50-50.

    edit:

    actually in a friendly league I'd let him do it 100% of the time.
Reply to Thread

Similar Threads