Check out our brand new Local Poker Communities! Get updates and interact with poker players in your area.
Visit the United States Poker Community | Visit the California Poker Community | Read more about the Launch of P5s Local

Settling the Best QB Debate Once and For All Contest - $$$

Reply to Thread
  1. ecu3270 ecu3270 is offline

    Greenville, NC
    United States

    Posts: 520
    Joined: Nov 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:13am)

    Beating a dead horse but lets settle the debate and stop the threads... by posting another thread.
    Here are the stats of eight of the best QB's in NFL history according to some of the names thrown around in the other posts and I threw in a few myself. After looking at unbiased stats, give me your top 3. Names, teams, rings left out. You can debate other things, such as postseason success, after getting a top 3 from these stats. Don't name the QBs if you know, I'll reveal them later.

    QB No. 1 153 games, 64.0 CP%, 39,972 yards, 291-149 (TD-INT), 94.2 rating. PEYTON MANNING

    QB No. 2 192 games, 63.2 CP%, 40,551 yards, 273-139 (TD-INT), 92.3 rating. JOE MONTANA

    QB No. 3 169 games, 64.3 CP%, 33,124 yards, 232-107 (TD-INT), 96.8 rating. STEVE YOUNG

    QB No. 4 242 games, 59.4 CP%, 61,361 yards, 420-252 (TD-INT), 86.4 rating. DAN MARINO

    QB No. 5 234 games, 56.9 CP%, 51,475 yards, 300-226 (TD-INT), 79.9 rating. JOHN ELWAY

    QB No. 6 250 games, 61.3 CP%, 60,257 yards, 430-281 (TD-INT), 85.5 rating. BRETT FAVRE

    QB No. 7 211 games, 54.6 CP%, 40,239 yards, 290-253 (TD-INT), 78.2 rating. JOHNNY UNITAS

    QB No. 8 105 games, 62.9 CP%, 24,250 yards, 180-82 (TD-INT), 92.2 rating. TOM BRADY

    Try not to use Google, but just for fun, $5 on Full Tilt to whoever names this "overrated QB" first whose stats I came across. He is regarded as a top QB in NFL history, but interesting stats say otherwise.

    Mystery QB 140 games, 50.1 CP%, 27,663 yards, 173-220 (TD-INT), 65.5 QB rating, and he tossed 20+ INTs in a season five times JOE NAMATH
  2. Phi Phi is offline aka tennisee

    Posts: 16,250
    Joined: Mar 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:15am) in reply to ecu3270

    For the Contest: Dan Marino

    For the Post:

  3. bgjoecool27 bgjoecool27 is offline

    Chicago, IL
    United States

    Posts: 782
    Joined: Jan 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:15am) in reply to ecu3270

    So we're going to use stats to get down to the top 3 then we'll discuss merit and other things like championships? That doesn't make sense. Why not discuss championships first then stats? We'll have three different quarterbacks. There is no right or wrong answer to this question. Your way is preposterous.
  4. Stritz Stritz is offline

    Posts: 1,816
    Joined: Apr 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:18am) in reply to ecu3270

    Mystery QB - Joe Namath
  5. ecu3270 ecu3270 is offline

    Greenville, NC
    United States

    Posts: 520
    Joined: Nov 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:20am) in reply to Stritz

    Stritz wins.
    Thread Starter
  6. Stritz Stritz is offline

    Posts: 1,816
    Joined: Apr 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:22am) in reply to ecu3270

    Sweet!!! I can use the money since I'm busto on all the sites.
  7. BigGunX BigGunX is offline Mr OT Party

    Williamsburg, VA
    United States

    Posts: 21,287
    Joined: Feb 05

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:23am) in reply to ecu3270

    Nice job compiling this stuff. I'm such a geek with stats that I'm pretty sure I can tell you 8 you have listed without looking it up. I'll let someone else take a stab....
     
  8. ecu3270 ecu3270 is offline

    Greenville, NC
    United States

    Posts: 520
    Joined: Nov 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:28am) in reply to BigGunX

    I'm a stat guy too, I just think the numbers and who people think are the best QBs would be surpising to most.
    Thread Starter
  9. calihockeyUSC calihockeyUSC is offline

    Newport Coast, CA
    United States

    Posts: 113
    Joined: Oct 07

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:30am) in reply to ecu3270

    I would pick QB No. 2, QB No. 4 and QB No. 6 as my top 3.

    Joe Namath or George Blanada is my guess for the Mystery QB
  10. BigGunX BigGunX is offline Mr OT Party

    Williamsburg, VA
    United States

    Posts: 21,287
    Joined: Feb 05

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:32am) in reply to ecu3270

    Oh yeah, definitely. That's what I mean. That's why I posted stuff about Unitas in that other thread. (#7 on your list.)
     
  11. Bigblind Popper Bigblind Popper is offline

    Gainesville, FL
    United States

    Posts: 1,850
    Joined: Jan 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:36am) in reply to ecu3270

    1,3,4. OBV i know who one of them is, as he is my favorite player. I cant believe you thought those shitty stats belonged to marino phil, have you been watching football this year?
  12. dippydough dippydough is offline

    Fitchburg, MA
    United States

    Posts: 2,970
    Joined: Mar 05

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 10:39am) in reply to ecu3270

    in order i would go. 8, 3, 1, 2, 4, 6, 5, 7.

    8,3,1 were all close for the top spot. then 2, 4, 6 are in tier 2. 5 and 7 have the worse stats by far, imo.
     
  13. ecu3270 ecu3270 is offline

    Greenville, NC
    United States

    Posts: 520
    Joined: Nov 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 12:49pm) in reply to dippydough

    Answers posted, ship the monies to Stritz
    Thread Starter
  14. BigDShaggyJ BigDShaggyJ is offline

    Port Coquitlam
    Canada

    Posts: 757
    Joined: Apr 07

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 3:18pm) in reply to ecu3270

    #1 and greatest of all time- COLT BRENNAN
     1
  15. Dissident Dissident is offline

    Posts: 8,282
    Joined: Jun 05

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 3:22pm) in reply to BigDShaggyJ

    so Testaverde wasnt the answer shucks
  16. Dissident Dissident is offline

    Posts: 8,282
    Joined: Jun 05

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 3:23pm) in reply to Dissident

    wait wait

    Neil O'Donnel?
  17. Problem xX Problem xX is offline

    Loveland, CO
    United States

    Posts: 110
    Joined: Dec 06

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 3:41pm) in reply to Dissident

    4,6,3 for top 3 stats+superbowl/team success
  18. weakone weakone is offline

    Saint Louis, MO
    United States

    Posts: 1,004
    Joined: Aug 07

    Nov 13th, 2007 (11/13/2007 4:03pm) in reply to ecu3270

    Kurt Warner had probably one of the best seasons of all time.
Reply to Thread