Off Topic Post

 
Sign in | Join
in
Bodog
$100K Guaranteed
Every Sunday! 
Sign Up Today!
Rakeback
Get cash back after
playing poker!
Sign up now!
CarbonPoker 
$15,000 Rake Chase
Plus 30% Rakeback!
Cake Poker 
33% Rakeback
$25k extra each month!

Off Topic


Please help support pocketfives by using our links when choosing to download a new site!
CarbonPoker · Full Tilt · Cake Poker · PokerStars · Ultimate Bet · Players Only · Bodog

   

Instant Replay is a Joke
orgnalsooners (United States) 1,396 Posts. Joined 11-14-2007.
11-07-2009 6:01 PM
Reply Quote

  For the life of me I don't understand how you can be a replay official and still get shit wrong. It happens every effin week and they just blew a huge call in the Bama/LSUgame( for the record I don't care who wins so this has nothing to do with anything) ...  Why is this so hard



 

 
 
 

LDM (United States) 5,368 Posts. Joined 02-13-2006.
11-07-2009 6:02 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

 the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.


orgnalsooners (United States) 1,396 Posts. Joined 11-14-2007.
11-07-2009 6:05 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

 

LDM: 

 the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.



  Instant replay was put into use to GET THE CALL RIGHT

   They did not and it wasn't that hard a decision since he got 2 feet in and only needed one

marinersheep (United States) 9,335 Posts. Joined 02-14-2006.
11-07-2009 6:05 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

LDM: 

 the original ruling decided that call, not the replay.


The worst part was that the first replay CBS showed, from behind the play (defense's perspective) CLEARLY showed BOTH feet come down in bounds. Instead they show the same two replays that give you no idea whether the right foot came down in bounds. Fact is he got BOTH feet down, and there was CLEAR evidence to overturn it. DVR the thing. Go back and look at the very first replay CBS showed. It's clear as day that he gets his right foot down in bounds, too.

FenwayKing (United States) 6,141 Posts. Joined 03-12-2006.
11-07-2009 6:06 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

LDM: 

 the sec cheating decided that call, not the replay.

fyp

LDM (United States) 5,368 Posts. Joined 02-13-2006.
11-07-2009 6:12 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

 you all do realize that you have to get a foot down AFTER possession right?  and because he was in the act of tucking the ball possession didn't start until it was tucked. 


i still think it was a pick, but a hell of a lot closer than what you guys thought.  and that's why replay didn't overturn.  the call on the field decided the play.


orgnalsooners (United States) 1,396 Posts. Joined 11-14-2007.
11-07-2009 6:13 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

 6:10 P.M. CST  marinersheep and orgnalsooners totally agree !!!!!   hope u did well with all stud 8 chips I gave u the other day...


marinersheep (United States) 9,335 Posts. Joined 02-14-2006.
11-07-2009 6:21 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

orgnalsooners: 

 6:10 P.M. CST  marinersheep and orgnalsooners totally agree !!!!!   hope u did well with all stud 8 chips I gave u the other day...


Nope, didn't even come close to doing well. It's Stud8. You know how it goes.

GPop21 (United States) 2,705 Posts. Joined 05-02-2006.
11-07-2009 6:22 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

when i read "instant replay is a joke" i couldn't help but be disappointed when i opened the thread and didn't see:


instant replay walked into a bar, then it walked into a bar again, slower. 


orgnalsooners (United States) 1,396 Posts. Joined 11-14-2007.
11-07-2009 6:30 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

LDM: 

 you all do realize that you have to get a foot down AFTER possession right?  and because he was in the act of tucking the ball possession didn't start until it was tucked. 


i still think it was a pick, but a hell of a lot closer than what you guys thought.  and that's why replay didn't overturn.  the call on the field decided the play.



 Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer?   The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND  2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here.  I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFO

LDM (United States) 5,368 Posts. Joined 02-13-2006.
11-07-2009 6:46 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

orgnalsooners: 
 Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer?   The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND  2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here.  I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFO
I didn't write the rules.  NCAA catch/possession rule about tucking a catch says it's possessed once tucked, not before.

There was only one foot in question after the tuck, and it was close.  I say it was in, Replay official said it wasn't enough to overturn.

The call on the field still decided.



swizbeatz (United States) 776 Posts. Joined 01-15-2007.
11-07-2009 6:48 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

 I didnt think it was a pick....


Trent55 (United States) 7,460 Posts. Joined 10-03-2005.
11-07-2009 6:51 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

college football reviews are god awful theres been plenty of calls that should have been overturned. i never thought id say this but i can hardly stand watching football anymore bc of the refs having so much influence these days!. mostly the gay ass touching the qb with your pinky and its an auto 15 yds. or the ball carrier lowers his shoulder and helmets make contact and you get 15 yds. its fucking embarassing


Trent55 (United States) 7,460 Posts. Joined 10-03-2005.
11-07-2009 6:52 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

swizbeatz: 

 I didnt think it was a pick....




lol nice level

BadAllergies (United States) 914 Posts. Joined 08-06-2008.
11-07-2009 7:14 PM - In reply to
Reply Quote

orgnalsooners: 
 Are u just an idiot or are u Bama homer?   The dude had CLEAR possession when it stuck to his damn hands... IT NEVER MOVED whatsoever... He had the ball AND  2 feet in and it's not even close... I am not going to reply to u again as I must be getting leveled here.  I guess u think Oregon wasn't offsides a few years ago versus Oklahoma either b/c those replay officials didn't reverse the call on the field either. GTFO


being a douche bag doesn't make your argument better.

Bama homer here.
 
Return to Top
Page 1 of 4 (46 items) 1 2 3 4 Next >


P5's Member Blogs
Free Poker Coaching (I Ne...
By Cre8ive - added Nov 18 2009, 02:38 AM
Hawaii
By rock3656 - added Nov 17 2009, 04:15 PM
Climbing a Mountain: Upd...
By mastaofkings - added Nov 18 2009, 09:19 AM
 
Joe Cada is our guest this week!  The newest WSOP Main Event Champion answers questions from P5s viewers.

P5s Podcast, Nov 19, 2009
Thur, 19 Nov 2009 12:00:00 EST
Jon 'apestyles' Van Fleet is back on the podcast this week to talk about the latest in his poker career.

P5s Podcast, Nov 12, 2009
Thur, 12 Nov 2009 12:00:00 EST
PocketFives.com Rankings
Rank PLB PRO
1. gboro780 3 1
2. djk123 1 3
3. Jovial Gent 2 4
4. moorman1 8 2
5. Doc Sands 5 6
6. rock3656 6 8
7. govshark2 7 7
8. ImaLuckSac 11 9
9. badpab2 4 19
10. brainwash 10 16
Carbon Poker Sorting Tables
Rank PLB
 1. djk123 9022.06
 2. Jovial Gent 8103.48
 3. gboro780 8001.66
 4. rock3656 7771.99
 5. govshark2 7645.73
 6. brainwash 7528.39
 7. 1SickDisease 7466.88
 8. ImaLuckSac 7369.79
 9. hoodini10 7327.57
 10. HITTHEPANDA 7271.41
Go